Pages

Visual Introduction of Characters

First Frames are Special

I've bumped into one phenomena about meaning in visual languages that had concrete gameplay consequences:

Adam started poor, THEN he became rich...
... but here it feels Adam was ALWAYS rich (if you ignore the caption).
Adam and Eve BECOME lovers, as Adam started alone...
... but here it feels like they were lovers before (again, if you ignore the first caption).

So it seems that whenever a new character is introduced, whatever state he is in that frame is projected into his past: if he shows up rich, he was always rich. If he shows up dead, he was dead long before the story started. If he is with someone, he has been with that person for a while, and so on... So to support this interpretation phenomena, I don't caption these "introductions" as actions anymore:

Old version.
No action: Adam was always rich.
Old version.
No action: they were always lovers.

First Appearance, not First Frame

For a long time, I assumed that these were special cases for the first frame of a strip, but later on I discovered that this "projection into the past" also triggers in later frames!

Second Frame: did Adam become rich or was always rich?

In this case, it also seems Adam was always rich because it's the first time he shows up in the story, so this frames becomes a sort of introductory situation. Therefore, whatever state a character is the first time he appears in the story, will be projected into his past.

First Appearance Stealing


Did Tim steal from Adam or not?
This setup makes it seem like Tim is *stealing* from Adam right in the first frame! This is because Adam and the chest and Tim are introduced at the same time and it reads like "Tim is a villain and he is with a treasure and Adam is there and so he was probably rich and Tim stole from him".

If I did that, I would need to support this case as well, because it's the first appearance of Adam together with the chest that allows this interpretation!

Here Tim should have stolen from Adam as well.

I implemented support for this "first appearance stealing" and some levels made use of it, but it turned out it is hard to remember these storytelling exceptions while you are playing the game so I disconnected the feature for the time being. But as with everything in Storyteller, it might come back in a different form!

17 comments:

  1. Out of curiosity, what were the first appearance stealing cases?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Also looks like frame dynamics affects interpretation too.

    If you put a frame with no caption of Adam and his chest, and then the frame "Tim envies Adam's riches" (where Adam is next to the chest, and Tim looks from behind Adam), is a quite self explanatory situation too, and the caption only adds silly literality.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that the game is overcaptioning right now. However, you'd be surprised at how much it helps when the stories are bigger and more complicated, and there's multiple feelings between characters...

      Delete
  3. The "Time envies Adam's riches" with no chest in the second picture, has several different interpretations in my mind. An object missing needs to be explained.

    Does Adam try to appear poor? (If there was a middle frame with Adam in a dungeon with the chest it would be obvious).
    Are the riches still there?

    And by adding Tim, his appearance somehow must be related to the missing chest.

    Did Adam hide his riches to not get robbed by Tim?
    Is Adam telling Tim of his riches?

    Stuff like that. Imagine two frames: First frame has Adam and a chest, second frame just Adam. Here Adam clearly lost his riches somehow. Of course here the addition of a bad-guy has significance, but how do you measure the importance between several events? (I think it is a really good idea to only have one event actually matter per frame).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, this interpretations you are making would be completely valid given the strip with no context. Storyteller does force some "rules of behavior" that restrict how things work and thus the "conforming" interpretations.

      In the case of the chest, the game assumes that the first person to get it became rich, and it will only be transferred to another if stolen or given.

      > (I think it is a really good idea to only have one event actually matter per frame)

      This is a very intersesting point, because deciding how and which things can happen at the same time is one of Storyteller's hard design problems. I should probably write about it...

      Delete
  4. I like to read your article because it really helps me. Thank you for sharing this post with us.
    Togel Online

    ReplyDelete
  5. Handmade jewellery are such stunning pieces of jewellery to have in your jewellery box. Handmade jewellery in UK that is made from sterling silver is so versatile and durable and these pieces can be worn with a range of outfits. These intricate pieces of handmade jewellery can be found in a range of different designs and styles. This means you will be able to find handmade jewellery that suits your personality and outfit.

    When you walk into the London Shop, you will know that you are receiving the most diverse range of handmade jewellery, not to mention other types such as evil eye jewellery, ear cuff collection and other silver jewellery. These collections are continuously renewed to ensure that customers can have a unique experience each time they set foot into our London shop.

    The jewellery with which we supply our stores is individually selected and designed using the most precious diamonds, pearls, gems and stones. Each of our handmade jewellery pieces come from fair trade sources.

    When people usually come across us, they think we just sell jewellery. Nothing could further from the truth. We don’t just sell jewellery, but we fill gaps. We supply the difference that you have for more diversity in your jewellery collection, and we fill the gap you have to show off your new evil eye jewellery or your silver jewellery. Still, also, we fill a huge gap in the UK market. One for intricate jewellery designs to make for thoughtful gifts or beautiful accessories, all at an affordable price.

    We are driven forward by our desire if making your special days even more special. We do this by providing our dazzling handmade jewellery and silver jewellery to customers just like you. Our extensive product range includes unique pieces such as uk silver rings, bracelets, earrings and ear cuffs in a range of colours. It is this kind of variety in shapes and colours which has made our jewellery collections some of the most widely appreciated in the UK and beyond.

    ReplyDelete